| | | | | | | | | | ABE | AR | BAR | BEL | BOW | BRO | CC | CEB | CH | CLA | CLI | COR | DAR | DL | GDA | HIL | HK | MAN | | MAY | MP | MER | MIA | OP | OTT | OXN | ROU | SAN | SAP | SPR | TON | ULA | UTI | VLA | WAS | WOO | YEL | | Team Index | Draft History | Starters: Positional - Pitchers | Registers: Batters - Pitchers | Leaders: Batters - Pitchers |  | Utica Fire Pitching Staff Chart |
| | Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 2007 19-35 | Manin 2-4, 6.61 | Abreu 1-2, 4.09 | | | | Abreu 0 SV, 4.09 | Manin 19 G, 6.61 | Abreu 18 G, 4.09 | | | 2008 17-37 | Álvarez 2-5, 5.47 | Perlta 1-5, 5.23 | Eida 1-3, 4.03 | Manin 1-1, 1.88 | Jones 1-3, 4.34 | Villanueva 6 SV, 5.57 | Villanueva 17 G, 5.57 | Jones 15 G, 4.34 | Álvarez 10 G, 5.47 | | 2009 27-27 | Perlta 5-4, 2.97 | Eliguashvili 3-4, 4.89 | Gutiérrez 1-3, 5.84 | Díaz 1-2, 2.42 | Harris 1-2, 4.50 | Harris 13 SV, 4.50 | Peterson 23 G, 6.29 | Harris 22 G, 4.50 | Villanueva 22 G, 2.13 | | 2010 15-39 | Eukepio 2-7, 6.52 | Hurtado 5-6, 2.70 | Ishida 1-4, 4.59 | Peterson 0-3, 5.31 | | Ishida 9 SV, 4.59 | Peterson 18 G, 5.31 | Ishida 17 G, 4.59 | Eukepio 12 G, 6.52 | | 2011 36-18 | Skinner 7-3, 3.24 | Perlta 6-2, 2.19 | Ponti 6-5, 3.75 | Ramos 7-2, 2.08 | Reyna 5-0, 1.40 | Kamida 2 SV, 4.70 | Johnson 15 G, 5.79 | Ponti 15 G, 3.75 | Skinner 14 G, 3.24 | | 2012 34-20 | Perlta 6-3, 3.71 | Reyna 7-5, 2.28 | Ramos 9-0, 1.28 | Xú 0-2, 3.16 | Skinner 3-2, 3.28 | Morin 10 SV, 0.82 | Johnson 21 G, 0.52 | Morin 14 G, 0.82 | Skinner 13 G, 3.28 | | 2013 29-25 | Dixon 3-4, 3.39 | | | | | Dixon 0 SV, 3.39 | Dixon 11 G, 3.39 | | | | 2014 23-31 | Miller 6-5, 3.38 | Dixon 0-2, 6.04 | Bryant 1-0, 0.47 | Juan 2-2, 1.71 | | Juan 13 SV, 1.71 | Juan 20 G, 1.71 | Miller 12 G, 3.38 | Bryant 11 G, 0.47 | | | Top 5 pitchers in Games Started, Top pitcher in Saves and Top 3 pitchers in Games | |