| | | | | | | | | | ALA | AND | AUN | BEN | BOS | CAM | CAR | CHA | DAV | DEL | GLE | HAG | HOL | HK | KIE | KIE | KIL | KNO | | LAN | LI | LYO | MAD | OMA | PET | PON | REN | ROC | SJ | SM | SAS | SE | TAI | TAS | TR | WAV | WO | | Team Index | Draft History | Starters: Positional - Pitchers | Registers: Batters - Pitchers | Leaders: Batters - Pitchers |  | Petaluma Atheists Pitching Staff Chart |
| | Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 2007 59-61 | Pak 8-8, 4.80 | Strauss 1-5, 6.75 | Taylor 0-1, 2.38 | | | Taylor 1 SV, 2.38 | Pak 24 G, 4.80 | Taylor 11 G, 2.38 | Strauss 6 G, 6.75 | | 2008 61-59 | González 11-12, 2.76 | Strauss 3-16, 7.00 | Pak 3-4, 3.29 | Lyon 1-0, 1.00 | Taylor 6-3, 3.02 | Taylor 33 SV, 3.02 | Taylor 47 G, 3.02 | González 28 G, 2.76 | Strauss 22 G, 7.00 | | 2009 62-58 | Strauss 8-11, 4.83 | González 2-0, 2.45 | Aberdein 4-3, 2.03 | Mailhot 0-1, 13.50 | | Aberdein 1 SV, 2.03 | Aberdein 34 G, 2.03 | Strauss 26 G, 4.83 | Mailhot 3 G, 13.50 | | 2010 86-34 | Strauss 15-5, 3.13 | Britton 11-4, 1.64 | Robinson 10-0, 1.43 | Vázquez 1-1, 6.00 | Baca 1-2, 2.61 | Baca 28 SV, 2.61 | Baca 39 G, 2.61 | Meléndez 33 G, 2.72 | Strauss 23 G, 3.13 | | 2011 71-49 | Vázquez 14-7, 4.61 | Jordan 11-7, 3.34 | Montalvo 0-1, 2.40 | Salas 2-1, 2.97 | Thornton 0-0, 0.00 | Thornton 9 SV, 0.00 | Montalvo 29 G, 2.40 | Young 28 G, 7.20 | Vázquez 25 G, 4.61 | | 2012 68-52 | Fajardo 9-7, 2.61 | Jordan 12-5, 3.75 | Morín 12-7, 3.75 | Hark 12-6, 3.24 | Sorensen 0-1, 13.50 | Young 25 SV, 6.04 | Montalvo 46 G, 2.54 | Salas 45 G, 1.83 | Young 44 G, 6.04 | | 2013 82-38 | Hatfield 12-6, 3.14 | Robinson 10-5, 2.87 | Vázquez 8-6, 4.09 | Palmer 15-3, 3.12 | Hark 9-2, 2.20 | García 26 SV, 2.89 | García 49 G, 2.89 | Young 42 G, 1.42 | Zamora 35 G, 1.42 | | 2014 77-43 | Rhodes 12-6, 3.14 | Hula 14-5, 2.82 | Reyes 9-5, 3.10 | Sorensen 13-4, 1.91 | Waltenbery 5-9, 4.45 | Lenoir 32 SV, 2.54 | Lenoir 39 G, 2.54 | Young 38 G, 3.47 | Robinson 27 G, 5.47 | | | Top 5 pitchers in Games Started, Top pitcher in Saves and Top 3 pitchers in Games | |