| | | | | | | | | | AUK | BAL | BIR | BOG | BUF | CAL | CHI | DM | DUB | GB | GRE | HAV | JAC | JOH | LV | LON | LB | LA | | LOU | MAN | MLA | MC | MOS | NY | PP | PAR | SJ | SD | SPO | SYD | TAI | TOK | VAL | VAN | WAR | WAS | | Team Index | Draft History | Starters: Positional - Pitchers | Registers: Batters - Pitchers | Leaders: Batters - Pitchers |  | Manhattan Myst Pitching Staff Chart |
| | Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 2007 85-77 | Chandler 11-12, 4.12 | Ortega 17-3, 1.58 | Macías 11-5, 3.24 | Peña 15-6, 4.22 | Salinas 7-6, 3.41 | Vázquez 20 SV, 2.16 | Trask 67 G, 3.16 | Morales 63 G, 3.77 | Johnston 57 G, 4.01 | | 2008 84-78 | Miranda 10-15, 4.14 | Ortega 12-6, 2.96 | Peña 10-11, 4.37 | McKain 10-6, 3.20 | Macías 12-5, 2.71 | López 18 SV, 4.38 | Trask 59 G, 2.13 | Morales 50 G, 3.83 | Rivera 49 G, 2.80 | | 2009 70-92 | Peña 10-13, 4.48 | Miranda 5-17, 4.80 | Ortega 15-7, 2.73 | McKain 13-6, 3.86 | Macías 3-9, 6.98 | Rivera 26 SV, 4.13 | Vázquez 68 G, 3.59 | Escada 58 G, 3.25 | Rivera 56 G, 4.13 | | 2010 76-86 | Ortega 17-7, 3.24 | Chávez 9-8, 4.23 | Escada 2-2, 3.47 | Johnston 6-6, 3.65 | Rivera 5-4, 3.91 | Ohayashi 28 SV, 3.38 | Vázquez 63 G, 3.28 | Rivera 59 G, 3.91 | Smith 49 G, 4.10 | | 2011 61-101 | Chávez 9-15, 3.81 | Muñíz 5-13, 4.95 | Shaw 1-13, 4.55 | Tengelei 6-19, 4.18 | Ito 6-8, 2.19 | Ohayashi 25 SV, 2.16 | Murnane 81 G, 2.99 | Rivera 73 G, 4.13 | Morales 63 G, 3.70 | | 2012 75-87 | Chávez 15-11, 3.42 | Ito 14-11, 3.60 | Tengelei 9-18, 5.72 | Yamada 8-11, 3.42 | Manin 5-7, 4.10 | Ohayashi 31 SV, 3.63 | Blackwell 65 G, 3.79 | Rivera 64 G, 5.04 | Benbow 57 G, 3.98 | | 2013 106-56 | Ito 21-5, 2.95 | Chávez 14-13, 3.61 | Pak 18-10, 3.28 | Ponti 19-11, 3.79 | Manin 5-4, 3.66 | Ohayashi 48 SV, 1.77 | Ohayashi 62 G, 1.77 | Blackwell 57 G, 3.53 | Vásquez 34 G, 4.95 | | 2014 0-0 | | | | | | | | | | | | Top 5 pitchers in Games Started, Top pitcher in Saves and Top 3 pitchers in Games | |